Tuesday, November 12, 2019

November 12, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Tuesday 11/12, I distributed 4 handouts: Assignment #2 (reproduced below)); the case you'll be briefing, Betton v. Belue; a newspaper article about the Betton case; and and a magazine article about a recent call for recusal of two Supreme Court Justices. We went over the requirements of Assignment #2, which we'll be discussing in class at more length on Thursday 11/14. We then went back to Caperton. We went over the successive layers of definitions involved in this situation: what is "due process"; what is a substantial risk of bias; what is a disproportional contribution? I then talked to the class about the case of Williams v. Pennsylvania, a more recent Supreme Court case that raised the question of recusal in the context of a former prosecutor in a case now serving as a judge. We looked at today's handout about the 2 Supreme Court Justices who met with a person whose organization had submitted an amicus brief in a pending Supreme Court case. Finally I went over the case of Overseers of the Bar v. Warren, a Maine Supreme Court case on the ethical responsibilities of Maine lawyers to turn in a colleague who is acting illegally.
The assignment for Thursday 11/14 is to begin work on your Betton case brief, read today's handouts, and review NFIB v. Sebelius, previously assigned.

Assignment due Thursday, November 21, 2019

The assignment (graded) is to do a Case Brief of the case of Betton v. Belue, ___F.3d___ (4th Cir., 2019) (also distributed to the class today).

Remember that the purpose of the brief is to be useful. Check your holdings to make sure that they give the most useful rules possible. Mere conclusory facts just tell us who won and who lost, but not what circumstances determine the winner and loser.

For this brief, include both the winner’s facts (“..., when...”) and the loser’s facts (“..., even though...”).


Follow the format from the Sample Briefs that I’ve distributed.

Note especially that, after the “Issue” is composed, the “Facts” and “Holding” are copied and pasted. Everything that you put into the Fact section should appear exactly in your Issue and Holding sections as well. Your Issue and Holding sections should be identical to each other, except that the issue is a question, and the Holding is the answer to that question. Your briefs will be evaluated on the format, as well as the specific content.

Please make two copies of your brief, one to hand in at the beginning of class, and the other for you to have during class for our discussion.

You may e-mail me if you have specific questions about the brief. The more time that I have to answer your questions, the more likely it is that I can be helpful.

If you cannot be in class on Thursday 11/24, you should still e-mail me your brief by the beginning of class time. If you do that, you will not have any grade deducted from your grade for the brief. If you do not, you should still contact me as soon as possible to see what options are available to you. (Generally, I do not want to accept assignments after we have discussed them in class). See the Syllabus for the class rules regarding late papers.

IMPORTANT: If you e-mail your brief to me, I will reply to confirm that I have received your assignment. If I do not reply, then I have not received the assignment.

Remember to work by yourselves; do not collaborate. Do not show your work to anyone else; do not look at anyone else’s work. Do not discuss your case brief with anyone but me. To the extent that we discuss this case in class, do not share that discussion with others, even if they have missed class. Do no outside research. Do not troll the internet. Just work from the handout itself. See the syllabus regarding plagiarism and collaboration.








POS 484 CRIMINAL DUE PROCESS
In class today, Tuesday 11/12, I returned the Mitchell outlines, as well as my comment key to those outlines. We then reviewed the exclusionary rule regarding good faith compliance with binding appellate authority. We compared that with the qualified immunity question of whether a rule of police use of force is clearly established. We went through the Court's opinion in Kisela, as well as Sotomayor's dissent. We saw how their view of previous cases was the mirror image of each other, in terms of which cases were right on point, and which cases were different. We also saw how Sotomayor was willing to look at precedent from other circuits which were more closely aligned with the facts of this case.
The assignment for Thursday 11/14 is to review what has already been assigned in Chapter 8 (p. 283-294), and to read in addition through p. 301 (including Schmerber).

Thursday, November 7, 2019

November 7, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Thursday 11/7, I first let the class know of my plan to distribute the next case brief assignment on Tuesday 11/12, with a planned due date of Thursday 11/21. We then finished our discussion of Glassford, looking at both substantive and procedural unconscionability, and severability. I then talked to the class about a 2018 SCOTUS case, Epic Systems v. Lewis, in which the Court 5-4 ruled on how the provisions of the 1925 Federal Arbitration Act interacted with the 1935 National Labor Relations Act. Then we began our discussion of Caperton v. Massey Coal. We had gotten as far as the background to the case, and looked at the standard used by Justice Benjamin for his refusal to recuse. We looked at the Tumey case, and will begin next Tuesday by comparing the standard used by Benjamin with the standard in Tumey.
The assignment for Tuesday 11/12 is to review Caperton, and to read in addition through p. 98 of the text,including NFIB v. Sebelius.



POS 484 CRIMINAL DUE PROCESS
In class today, Thursday 11/7, I collected the Mitchell outlines, and we went over them. I also distributed my version of the outline. I plan to grade them this weekend and return them on Tuesday.
We then went back to Davis. I explained how the majority and the dissent had different views on the relationship between retroactivity analysis and the exclusion of evidence. We also discussed how the Davis view of the good faith exception to suppression expanded on previous incarnations of the good faith exception. We began our discussion of qualified immunity and the Kisela case. We will pick up on Tuesday with the majority's decision about which issue to address, the existence of a constitutional violation, or the existence of qualified immunity, and how the dissent viewed the same question.
The assignment for Tuesday 11/12 is to review Kisela, and review Tuesday's handout on recent Court of Appeals qualified immunity cases, and to read in the textbook pp. 283-294, including Connelly.

Tuesday, November 5, 2019

November 5, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Tuesday 11/5, we first finished going through the Maine statutes involving the duty to report. We then turned to Lawrence v. Texas. We discussed how Kennedy dealt with the question of whether to treat the case as a due process or as an equal protection issue. We looked at how he analyzed the issue in terms of fundamental rights (high hurdles) versus non-fundamental rights (low hurdles). We also discussed the question of whether the majority can criminalize conduct simply because the majority feels that the conduct is wrong. I also talked about O'Connor's concurrence in the case, and the dissent. Then we began our discussion of Glassford. We talked about arbitration clauses in general, and the provisions of this arbitration clause in particular. We went over the prior proceedings, and we'll pick up on Thursday with the Court's analysis.
The assignment for Thursday 11/7 is first to review Glassford. Brief the issues in the case (not handed in or graded). In addition, read to the end of Chapter 2, including Caperton v. Massey coal.




POS 484 CRIMINAL DUE PROCESS
In class today, Tuesday 11/5, I distributed one handout, a list of recent Court of Appeals cases involving qualified immunity for law enforcement. I began by reminding the class of the Mitchell outline due Thursday. In terms of length of the outline/summaries, I said that my total paper was 3 pages. I discussed how Sotomayor's dissent in Mitchell may require more than one paragraph in explanation of her views. I then talked about the 2018 Maine Supreme Court case of State v. Lemeunier-Fitzgerald, in which the Court split 4-3 over the question of whether Maine's implied consent law (distributed last week) in fact counted as constitutionally sufficient consent to a blood draw, or whether it was instead too coercive to constitute real consent.
We then turned to a new topic of enforcement of the 4th Amendment. We talked about two possible methods of enforcement, exclusion of unconstitutionally seized evidence, and civil suits against the officers who violate the constitutional rules. I went over a case from the textbook that I had not assigned, Utah v. Strieff (p.400) in which the Court found that an intervening factor (an outstanding warrant) meant that the evidence that was seized through an unconstitutional stop should still be admitted as evidence. We then talked about the good faith exception to the exclusionary rule. I discussed Leon and Evans, two case that were included in today's assignment. I talked about who exactly was the party that made the error in those cases. Then we went through the Herring case, discussing the levels of culpability (intent, recklessness, etc.) and how Herring expanded the exceptions to the exclusionary rule. We began our discussion of Davis v. U.S., and saw how it fit within the good faith exception to the exclusionary rule. We will pick up on Thursday with how the retroactive application of Arizona v. Gant was viewed by both the majority and the dissent.
The assignment for Thursday 11/7 is to finish up your Mitchell v. Wisconsin outlines, due at the beginning of class on 11/7. Review Davis, read today's handout, and read in the text p. 432-440, including Kisela v. Hughes.

Thursday, October 31, 2019

October 31, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Thursday 10/31, we first finished our discussion of Gregg v. Georgia. We then went through State v. Mobbley, and followed that by looking at the Maine statute regarding hindering apprehension. We then went over Holland v. Florida, and again looked at the Maine statutes regarding the creation of common law crimes, and the Massachusetts and federal laws that create a criminal responsibility for failure to report certain crimes. We will pick up next Tuesday with those Maine statutes that do create a responsibility to report in certain limited situations..
The assignment for Tuesday 11/5 is to read in the textbook through p.77, including Lawrence v. Texas and Glassford v. BrickKicker.


POS 484 CRIMINAL DUE PROCESS
In class today, Thursday 10/31, I distributed 4 handouts: excerpts from the Maine drunk driving statutes; Scalia's concurrence in Gant; the case that the subject of the "You Decide" 6.5 from p. 205, Taylor v. State; and a case on a new subject, Davis v. U.S. We first went over the majority and dissenting opinions in Gant, and then talked about Scalia's concurrence. We then went over the Maryland Taylor case (You Decide 6.5), and how it dealt with the issue of car searches after an arrest for drunk driving. We then looked at the Maine drunk driving statutes, and also talked about a whole other way to search a car after an arrest without a warrant, an "inventory" search. I also talked about S. Dakota v. Opperman, which allowed these inventory searches.
The assignment for Tuesday 11/5 is to continue working on your Mitchell outlines, and to read all 4 of today's handouts. In addition, read p. 402-408 of the text, including Herring v. U.S.

Tuesday, October 29, 2019

October 29, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Tuesday 10/29, I handed back the exams, and we went over them. I distributed one handout, excerpts from the Maine and federal statutes about hindering apprehension, common law crimes, duty to report crimes, etc. We started going over Gregg v. Georgia, and last week's handout about the story of the capital punishment cases. We got through the Stewart plurality opinion, and will pick up on Thursday with the dissents.
The assignment for Thursday 10/31 is to review the dissents in Gregg, read in the text through p. 67 (including Mobbley and Holland) and read today's statutory handout.


POS 484 CRIMINAL DUE PROCESS
In class today, Tuesday 10/29, I distributed one handout, an article about the upcoming Supreme Court argument in Kansas v. Glover, involving the definition of reasonable suspicion in the context of suspended licenses. We then turned to Mitchell v. Wisconsin, whose outline is due next Thursday 11/7. I went through the three theories of why warrantless blood alcohol tests may be reasonable: search incident to arrest; implied consent; and exigency. We saw how, for blood tests, search incident to arrest had already been foreclosed. We also saw how the Court plurality in Mitchell decided not to rule on the implied consent issue, and to instead tackle exigency. We looked at the previous exigency/drunk driving case, Missouri v. McNeely, how the plurality dealt with McNeely, and how the dissent disagreed with the plurality. We looked at the breakdown of the votes in both McNeely and Mitchell, and saw how a change in Court personnel made all the difference, as none of the Justices really changed what side they were on.
The assignment for Thursday 10/31 is to read in the text pp. 200-205, including Arizona v. Gant, as well as reading today's handout.

Thursday, October 24, 2019

October 24, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Thursday 10/24, the class took Exam #1. I plan to grade the exams this weekend, and return them on Tuesday. I also distributed one handout, an article about capital punishment history in the Supreme Court.
The assignment for Tuesday 10/29 is to review Gregg v. Georgia (previously assigned, and to read in addition today's handout.



POS 484 CRIMINAL DUE PROCESS
In class today, Thursday 10/24, I handed back the exams, and we went over them. I distributed two handouts: Assignment #2 (reproduced below) and the case you'll be outlining, Mitchell v. Wisconsin. We went through the requirements of the assignment. Then we discussed exigent circumstances and the Welsh v. Wisconsin case assigned for today.
The assignment for Tuesday 10/29 is to read Mitchell and start work on your outline.

Assignment due Thursday, November 7, 2019

The assignment is to do an outline of Justice Alito's opinion in Mitchell v. Wisconsin (also distributed to the class today). In addition, write a short paragraph for each of the opinions by Thomas, Sotomayor, and Gorsuch (so, three paragraphs that will follow the Alito outline), which explain the major point(s) made by the opinion, especially how it deals with Alito's plurality opinion.

For the outline, follow the format from the Sample Outlines that I’ve distributed. Use Titles for the Roman numerals, and then Question and Answer for all the other elements. Both the questions and the answers should be complete sentences.

The structure should go like this:
Roman numeral; Capital Letter; Numbers; Lower Case Letter.
For example:
I. (Title)
A. (Question and Answer)
1. (Question and Answer)
2. (Question and Answer)
a. (Question and Answer)
b. (Question and Answer)
B. (Question and Answer)
II. (Title)

Follow the structure already provided by Justice Alito:
I.
(A.)
(B.)
II.
III.
(A.)
(B.)
(1.)
(2.)
IV.

Add Introductory Sections and sub-elements to this as is appropriate, but don’t alter Alito's structure. What makes an addition appropriate? Basically, when Alito is addressing a different question. When you add elements, italicize the heading, numbers or letters of your additions. There are Introductory sections in ¶1-2, 15, and 26-27.

If there’s a (1), there should be a (2). If you’ve only got one thing to say, just say it without the further division.

Here’s my suggestion for the best way to proceed: First, figure out what the thought is for each paragraph. Second, group the paragraphs together in terms of what question they are addressing. Last, put the actual questions in, with the roman numerals questions as the final thing. In other words, work from smallest to largest.

The assignment will be graded on both the structure and the content of your outline. The outline will also be graded on how well you write English, and how clearly you organize your thoughts. I like short clear sentences better than long complicated ones. I like correct grammar.

Please make two copies of your outline, one to hand in at the beginning of class, and the other for you to have during class for our discussion.

You may e-mail me if you have specific questions about the assignment. The more time that I have to answer your questions, the more likely it is that I can be helpful.

If you cannot be in class on Thursday 11/7, you should still e-mail me your assignment by the beginning of class time. If you do that, you will not have any grade deducted from your grade for the outline. If you do not, you should still contact me as soon as possible to see what options are available to you. (Generally, I do not want to accept assignments after we have discussed them in class). See the Syllabus for the class rules regarding late papers.

The work should be entirely your own, with no collaboration or plagiarism. Do not show your paper to anyone. Do not look at anyone else’s paper. Do not do any outside research. Just work from the handout itself. Do not troll the internet. See the syllabus regarding plagiarism and collaboration.


IMPORTANT: If you e-mail your assignment to me, I will reply to confirm that I have received your assignment. If you do not get a reply, then I have not received the assignment.





Tuesday, October 22, 2019

October 22, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Tuesday 10/22, I distributed 3 handouts: my version of the Bishop case brief; the comment key to my comments on your case briefs; and a sample test in preparation for Thursday's test. I handed back your Bishop case briefs, and we went over them and the comment key. We the finished up our discussion of Suggs v. Norris, and I went over a Maine case, Paffhausen v. Balano, that also asked about contract formation in the context of a claim against an estate. I also discussed citation form for all levels of the federal court system: U.S. District Courts, U.S. Courts of Appeal, and the U.S. Supreme Court.
On Thursday 10/24, the class will take Exam #1. If you are missing any handouts, email me by 8:00 pm on Wednesday 10/23 with your requests. Remember that the exam is open book and open note, and those using laptops or other devices may not perform any searches or other operations that those having paper materials are unable to perform.


POS 484 CRIMINAL DUE PROCESS
In class today, Tuesday 10/22, the class took Exam #1. I plan to hand the exams back and go over them on Thursday.
The assignment for Thursday 10/24 is to read in the text pp. 152-159, including Welsh v. Wisconsin.