Thursday, March 7, 2019

March 7, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Thursday 3/7, I distributed one handout, the Maine criminal statutes regarding the use of force in defense of property and premises. (That handout, though, will not be included in the material for which you are responsible for Tuesday's exam). We began class by going over the Speelman hypotheticals that I had handed out on Tuesday. We looked at how closing your eyes can work out in your favor. I then talked about a 2006 U.S. Supreme Court case, Jones v. Flowers, in which the Court dealt with the Due Process requirements when an important notice is returned as undeliverable. The Court also discussed the scope of responsibilities on the sender regarding further attempts to get the notice delivered, and the responsibility to do further investigation into the correct address. We then turned to Katko v. Briney in the textbook. We went through the case brief of the case as far as the "facts" in the first issue in the case (whether the thief can recover when he was shot in the course of his thieving ways). That's where we'll pick up on Thursday after we go over Tuesday's exam.
On Tuesday 3/12 we will have Exam #1. Remember that if you're using a laptop etc., you may not use it in any way that a person having just paper cannot do. If you find in your review of the blog that you are missing any handouts, you can email me no later than 8:00 pm on Monday with your request for a copy of what you're missing.


POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Thursday 3/7, we first finished our discussion of the Madison opinion. I pointed out a few points in Kagan's opinion that I found of particular interest. One was in Kagan's discussion of the ability (or lack of ability) to preserve memories, even though the lack of memory is not, in itself, sufficient for a finding of incompetency. The other was in her discussion of the procedure that should be followed by the Alabama competency court on remand, with her strong suggestion that there should be a new round of evidence, even though she didn't find that that court had committed error in their previous ruling. Then we went over the dissent, and saw how they got to the conclusion that the Court was ruling on issues that weren't properly before it, and Madison's case should therefore be dismissed.
We then turned to the Timbs opinion, and saw how in that case as well, the Court dealt with the issue of one one the contentions of the state of Indiana (that Austin should be overruled) would not be dealt with, because it was not raised in the Questions Presented in the Cert. Petition. We saw how Ginsburg had little trouble then with the incorporation question, as well as the state's contention that protections against in rem forfeitures were neither fundamental nor deeply rooted. We finally looked at Thomas' concurrence, in which he refused to go along with Due Process as the vehicle for incorporation, but rather used the 14th Amendment Privileges or Immunities Clause
On Tuesday 3/12 we will have Exam #1. Remember that if you're using a laptop etc., you may not use it in any way that a person having just paper cannot do. If you find in your review of the blog that you are missing any handouts, you can email me no later than 8:00 pm on Monday with your request for a copy of what you're missing.

Tuesday, March 5, 2019

March 5, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Tuesday 3/5, I distributed 3 handouts: the Comment Key to the Carter case briefs, my version of the Speelman case brief, and some hypotheticals with variations on the Speelman case. I handed back the Carter case briefs, and we went over some aspects of the Comment Key, especially those things that are not "Facts". We then went over some sample questions in preparation for next Tuesday's Exam #1, including case citations and statutory citations. We went through the Speelman case and saw how the language of their letter sank the BHA's case. We will begin on Thursday with today's handout of hypotheticals, and then I want to go over the U.S. Supreme Court case involving the address on the envelope, Jones v. Flowers.
The assignment for Thursday 3/7 is to read today's handouts, prepare to discuss the hypotheticals, and read in the text and prepare to discuss pp. 38-43, including Katko v. Briney.


POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Tuesday 3/5, we first went over some sample questions in preparation for next Tuesday's Exam #1. We reviewed the Dunn v, Madison opinion of the Supreme Court, which said the the federal 11th Circuit had been wrong to say that the Alabama state competency court had been unreasonable in its application of the Ford/Panetti standard. We then went through the majority opinion in last week's Madison opinion, paying special attention to the outline of Kagan's opinion. There were two paragraphs of Kagan's opinion that I still want to spend more time on: ¶17 (and a word from ¶21) in terms of memory and ¶26 in terms of evidence and experts. We'll then go to the Madison dissent. And from there we'll go the the Timbs opinion, previously distributed.
The assignment for Thursday 3/7 is to review the Madison opinion, and to read (if you haven't done so already) the Timbs opinion.

Thursday, February 28, 2019

February 28, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Thursday 2/28, I collected the Carter case briefs, and I also distributed my own version of the brief. I plan to grade them this weekend, and return them on Tuesday. We spent the class period going over the case and the case brief.
I also laid out a scheduling plan for the next two weeks. I plan to give some practice exam questions on Tuesday 3/5, and to give Exam #1 on Tuesday 3/12.
The assignment for Tuesday 3/5 is to read in the text pp. 34-38, including Speelman v. Bellingham Housing Authority.


POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Thursday 2/28, I distributed 2 handouts: the 2017 Supreme Court opinion in Dunn v. Madison, and the 2/27/2019 (yesterday) opinion in Madison v. Alabama. We first went over the procedural story of the Dunn v. Madison opinion, and the effect of the federal AEDPA statute on the ability to get these issues into federal court. We also looked at both the Ginsburg and Breyer concurrences in that case. We then turned to the Madison oral argument. We saw how the Justices eventually got Stevenson to concede on Issue #1 that loss of memory alone was not sufficient for a finding of incompetency, but that it was somewhat confusing what qualified as the "plus" to add to loss of memory. We also saw how one looming question was whether the state competency judge had in fact ruled out dementia as a cause of incompetency, or, alternatively, had allowed it but hadn't found that the dementia in this case had met the Panetti standard. We will pick up briefly on Tuesday with the question of whether it was Alabama's position that dementia could not be the source of incompetency.
I also laid out a scheduling plan for the next two weeks. I plan to give some practice exam questions on Tuesday 3/5, and to give Exam #1 on Tuesday 3/12.
The assignment for Tuesday 3/5 is to read today's 2 Madison opinion handouts. The plan then for next Thursday is to discuss the Timbs opinion which I had distributed to the class on 2/21.

Tuesday, February 26, 2019

February 26, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Tuesday 2/26, I distributed one handout, my version of the Carter issues that were not assigned for the case brief. We did go over those non-assigned issues by putting them in the case brief format. Along the way, I talked about various levels of persuasion (beyond a reasonable doubt; clear and convincing; preponderance of the evidence; probable cause to believe; reasonable suspicion; a hunch). We went over the difference between an objective standard versus a subjective standard. We also went over the concept of the discretion of a trial judge, and how the appellate court just polices the outer boundaries of that discretion. We also reviewed the concept of dictum.
The assignment for Thursday 2/28 is to finish your Carter case brief, due at the beginning of Thursday's class.


POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Tuesday 2/26, we began by reviewing the holding of Panetti. We also looked at some of the intricacies of habeus corpus, including deference (or not) by the federal proceeding to state court findings. We also discussed mandatory authority (versus persuasive authority) in terms of the federal District Court and the U.S. Court of Appeals decisions in Panetti. We then turned to Madison. We looked at the dispute over the formulation of the Question Presented in the case. We talked about whether the lack of memory of the crime itself was enough to negate competency. We discussed the two problems of lying about memory and blackouts and fugue states. We also went over the roles of the desire to be civilized in our executions, and the relationship between that and the lack of memory of the crime.
The assignment for Thursday 2/28 is to review the Madison briefs and especially the Madison oral argument.

Thursday, February 21, 2019

February 21, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Thursday 2/21, we first went through Souter's concurrence in Glucksberg. We talked about his views on the characterization of the asserted right, and the reason that he nonetheless voted against the doctors. Along the way, I went over three recurring institutional conflicts in the law: the rights of the individual versus the power of government; the tension in a federal system between the power of the federal government versus the power of the state governments; and the separation of powers between the executive, the legislative, and the judicial branches. We then turned to the Carter case that is the subject of next week's graded case brief assignment. We went over correct citation form for the case, and discussed the Massachusetts common law (non-statutory) crime of which she was convicted. We looked at the sufficiency of the evidence issue, and saw how it was really divided into two separate issues, ¶10-11 and then ¶12-16. We then took one of the issues that is not included in the assignment (for the Issue, Facts, and Holding segments), the Due Process issue of vagueness. We worked through the formulation of that issue. We refined our initial stab at the legal question ("...does the common law provide sufficient notice of the elements of involuntary manslaughter...") to the more specific ("...does the common law provide sufficient notice of whether instructing a victim to kill himself "causes" the victim's death..."). We will work together through the other 2 non-assigned issues in Carter (free speech and expert witness) next Tuesday.
The assignment for Tuesday 2/26 is to continue your work on the Carter case brief, due at the beginning of class 2/28.



POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Thursday 2/21, I distributed one handout, yesterday's Supreme Court opinion in Timbs v. Indiana. I started class talking about a Court decision this week, Moore v. Texas, in which the Court ruled in another competency to execute case, this one about intellectual disability (as opposed to Madison and dementia). I went over how the Court majority found that the instructions that it had previously given to the Texas court had been ignored, and how that's one way to get to take a case for the second time. We also went through the specific ways in which the intellectual disability had been evaluated by Texas (twice) and what the Court found was wrong with that evaluation. I briefly talked about the dissent in the case as well. We then returned to Panetti. I went over the problem that the Court identified with the Court of Appeals decision in the case: looking only at the prisoner's awareness of the state's reason for the execution, as opposed to the prisoner himself having a rational understanding of the reason for the execution. I want to begin next week with a look at mandatory authority used by Panetti, and the role of trial courts in findings of fact.
The assignment for Tuesday 2/26 is review both the majority and dissenting opinions in Panetti; review the Madison briefs; and listen to and read the oral argument in Madison.

Tuesday, February 19, 2019

February 19, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Tuesday 2/19, I distributed 3 handouts: my version of the Glucksberg case brief; Assignment #1 (reproduced below); and the case you'll be briefing, Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Carter.
We first finished out discussion of the majority decision in Glucksberg. We reviewed the flow chart of whether due process protects individual rights against what the legislature restricts. We did Venn diagrams of personal autonomy and fundamental rights, and of the rationale for government restrictions and the actual restrictions imposed. We also talked about the use of precedent, and we discussed three options when dealing with precedent: following it (the same side wins because the context is the same; overruling it (because the prior case was wrongly decided); and distinguishing it (the different side wins because the context is different). We then went through the Maine statutory handout from last week on murder and assisted suicide, and did as much as we could to figure out the meaning of the terms used in those statutes. We also reviewed Maine statutory citation form. We went through the excerpt from Obergefell that I handed out last week, seeing how the Court majority treated the Glucksberg flow chart, and then saw what Roberts in dissent thought of the majority's adherence to Glucksberg.
On Thursday we will begin by discussing Souter's concurrence in Glucksberg. Then we will discuss the Carter case that's the subject of the case brief.
The assignment for Thursday 2/21 is to review Souter's concurrence in Glucksberg, and then to read and be prepared to discuss all of the Michelle Carter case.

Assignment due Thursday, February 28, 2019

The assignment (graded) is to do a Case Brief of the case of Commonwealth v. Carter, __Mass.__ (2019) (also distributed to the class today).

For the Issue, Facts, and Holding, I want you to only include Issues “a” (Sufficiency of the evidence); “d” “Infliction” of serious bodily injury; and “e” “Reasonable juvenile”. I do want you to read all of the Opinion, though, as well as to include all of the arguments in the other portions of the brief, including “appellant’s contentions on appeal”.

Remember that the purpose of the brief is to be useful. Check your holdings to make sure that they give the most useful rules possible. Mere conclusory facts just tell us who won and who lost, but not what circumstances determine the winner and loser.

For this brief, include only the winner’s facts (“..., when...”) and not the loser’s facts (“..., even though...”)

Follow the format from the Sample Briefs that I’ve distributed.

Note especially that, after the “Issue” is composed, the “Facts” and “Holding” are copied and pasted. Everything that you put into the Fact section should appear exactly in your Issue and Holding sections as well. Your Issue and Holding sections should be identical to each other, except that the issue is a question, and the Holding is the answer to that question. Your briefs will be evaluated on the format, as well as the specific content.

Please make two copies of your brief, one to hand in at the beginning of class, and the other for you to have during class for our discussion.

You may e-mail me if you have specific questions about the brief. The more time that I have to answer your questions, the more likely it is that I can be helpful.

If you cannot be in class on Thursday 2/28, you should still e-mail me your brief by the beginning of class time. If you do that, you will not have any grade deducted from your grade for the brief. If you do not, you should still contact me as soon as possible to see what options are available to you. (Generally, I do not want to accept assignments after we have discussed them in class). See the Syllabus for the class rules regarding late papers.

IMPORTANT: If you e-mail your brief to me, I will reply to confirm that I have received your assignment. If I do not reply, then I have not received the assignment.

Remember to work by yourselves; do not collaborate. Do not show your work to anyone else; do not look at anyone else’s work. Do not discuss your case brief with anyone but me. To the extent that we discuss this case in class, do not share that discussion with others, even if they have missed class. Do no outside research. Do not troll the internet. Just work from the handout itself. See the syllabus regarding plagiarism and collaboration.





POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Tuesday 2/19, I handed back the Gamble papers, and we went over them. I also went over the Kagan and Gorsuch questions about the effect that incorporation had on the dual sovereigns exception. We began our discussion of Madison by going over the 1970s cases of Furman v. Georgia and Gregg v. Georgia, in which the Supreme Court found that execution was not "cruel and unusual" as long as there was justification for the execution (and there were proper procedures for imposing execution as a penalty). A plurality held that, while deterrence did not provide a justification, retribution did. I then went over the 1986 case of Ford v. Wainwright, in which a plurality held that retribution was not a sufficient justification for execution of the insane. We will pick up on Thursday with the handout of the Panetti case, and continue onto the Madison briefs.
The assignment for Thursday 2/21 is to review Panetti v. Quarterman, and the Madison v. Alabama briefs, previously distributed.

Thursday, February 14, 2019

February 14, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Thursday 2/14, I distributed 2 handouts: the Maine assisted suicide statute, and an excerpt from the same-sex marriage case, Obergefell v. Hodges. We began class by going over Brittany Maynard's article regarding her right to make the decision to die on her own terms. We then started working our way through the Glucksberg case brief, getting up to the doctors' argument that the issue has already been decided by prior cases. That's where we'll pick up next week. We saw how the Court went about defining the "right" that's being examined, and how to decide if that right is "fundamental". Along the way, we also went over the difference between a "panel" decision of the Court of Appeals, versus an "en banc" opinion.
The assignment for Tuesday 2/19 is to continue work on the Glucksberg case brief, and to read today's two handouts.



POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Thursday 2/14, I first collected the Gamble papers, and we went over them a little by discussing the first question of the assignment. I distributed three handouts for our next case: Petitioner's and Respondent's Briefs in Madison v. Alabama, and the previous Supreme Court case of Panetti v. Quarterman. We went back to the Timbs case. We discussed three ways of dealing with precedent: following, overruling, or distinguishing. We discussed how Timbs wants Austin followed, while Indiana can go with with overruling or distinguishing. We went over the three hurdles for Timbs to win (incorporation; "fine"; "excessive") and how much of the oral argument concerned the "excessive" definition, even though that issue had not been the one on which cert. was granted. We saw in the oral argument why that might have been the case: the reluctance to either open the door to an abyss (no definition of "excessive" makes sense) or to a brick wall (in rem forfeiture will never be excessive). That concludes our study of Timbs.
The assignment for Tuesday 2/19 is to read today's three handouts in Madison v. Alabama. If you are not sated, you can go on to listen to oral argument, though it's not formally assigned until next week.