Tuesday, February 12, 2019

February 12, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Tuesday 2/12, I distributed one handout, an article about assisted suicide. I began class by covering a 2016 Supreme Court decision, Montgomery v. Louisiana, that took up the question of the retroactive application of the Miller decision. We looked at both the majority and the dissenting opinions in Montgomery, as well as the votes in the case. We talked about the substantive/procedural divide in terms of retroactive application, as well as the Court's power to say what exactly they had previously decided in Miller. We then looked at the Maine sentencing statute that I had handed out last week, and we went over statutory citation form. We then went through the concept of due process, the history of the 14th Amendment, substantive due process, and the relationship between the 5th Amendment Due Process Clause versus the 14th Amendment Due Process Clause.
The assignment for Thursday 2/14 is to read today's handout, and to finish work on your version of the Glucksberg case brief (not handed in or graded).



POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Tuesday 2/12, I first reminded the class of the Gamble paper due at the beginning of class on Thursday. We then took a deeper dive into the Timbs excessive fines case. We went through the three issues on which Timbs has to eventually prevail in order to win: incorporation; "fines"; and "excessive". We looked at incorporation and its history, including a review of the podcast on Privileges or Immunities, and the logical problem of using 14th Amendment Due Process to incorporate the Bill of Rights (since the 5th Amendment Due Process Clause could not have encompassed all of the other Bill of Rights protections). We then looked at whether in rem forfeitures are a "fine". I went over two earlier cases: Austin v. U.S. and U.S. v. Bajakajian. We went over how Bajakaian might be read to undermine Austin, and why that's important to Indiana's case. We also talked about how the existence (or non-existence) of an innocent owner exception can be used to help decide whether a forfeiture is "punishment".
The assignment for Thursday 2/14 is to finish your Gamble paper, and to review the briefs and the oral argument in Timbs.

Thursday, February 7, 2019

February 7, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Thursday 2/7, I distributed three handouts: my version of the Miller case brief, an excerpt from the Maine sentencing statutes, and a recent commentary by the ACLU about the due process rights involved in university investigation of campus sexual assault and harassment. We first finished going through the Miller case brief. I then talked about four juvenile sentencing cases prior to Miller: Thompson v. Oklahoma; Sanford v. Kentucky; Roper v. Simmons; and Graham v. Florida. We went over the votes in those cases, as well as the votes in Miller. Along the way, I discussed the difference between a concurrence in the judgment versus a concurrence in the opinion. We went over Breyer's concurrence, as well as the Roberts and Thomas dissents. I will pick up on Tuesday with Montgomery v. Louisiana, the 2016 U.S. Supreme Court case that addressed the question of the retroactive application of Miller, and the scope of the Miller holding.
The assignment for Tuesday 2/12 is to read today's handouts, and to read in the text through p. 34. Do a practice case brief of Glucksberg (not handed in or graded).


POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Thursday 2/7, we first talked about the Institute for Justice podcast on the Privileges or Immunities Clause. We talked about incorporation of the Bill of Rights through the Privileges or Immunities Clause, as well as other, unenumerated rights such as the right to travel, make contracts or have an occupation. I took an informal poll of the class regarding the interest in another current Institute for Justice case about the right of a state to limit its alcohol sellers to long-time in-state residents. We then began our discussion of the Timbs case. I went over the briefs in terms of sympathy for the drug dealer/ bereaved son; dictum from prior Supreme Court cases; in rem as either a "fine" or not a "fine"; and the test for incorporation. I talked a little about the Austin case, which I will go through in more detail next week.
The assignment for Tuesday 2/12 is to 1) continue work on your Gamble paper, due next Thursday; 2)review the Timbs' briefs, and then 3)listen to the Timbs oral argument at
https://www.oyez.org/cases/2018/17-1091
Remember to bring with you to class some form (paper or otherwise) of the transcript of the oral argument.

Tuesday, February 5, 2019

February 5, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Tuesday 2/5, we began by going over the introductory section of the textbook (pp. 1-15). We discussed the 5 jurisprudential approaches and the 4 objectives of the law. I went over the definition of "common law" that we will be using in our class ("judge-made law in the absence of enacted law"). We went over the echo of the courts of equity still reflected in the ability of the Maine Superior Courts (as opposed to the Maine District Courts) to have broad power to grant equitable relief. We then began our discussion of Miller. We went through the case brief down to the formulation of the "issue", in which we got through the segments of "under what law" and "the legal question". We left off at the "facts", which is where we'll pick up on Thursday.
The assignment for Thursday 2/7 is to continue refining your Miller case brief (not handed in or graded), and review and read through p.23.


POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Tuesday 2/5, I distributed 3 handouts: Assignment #1 (reproduced below); and the Petitioner's and Respondent's Briefs in Timbs v. Indiana.
We went over the requirements of the assignment. We then discussed several additional aspects of the Gamble oral argument: the split on the Court regarding whether original meaning is the only correct way to define the terms of the constitution; the consequences of using original meaning; and the responsibility (or lack thereof) of the Court to get the constitutional meaning right, even if it was wrong in the past. We then had a chance to both predict the outcome of the case, and to briefly discuss what we think the correct result should be.
We will pick up on Thursday with the Timbs case, starting with the Institute for Justice podcast on Privileges or Immunities, and then moving to the briefs that I distributed today.

Assignment #1 due Thursday, February 14th

One of the things we’ve been looking at in Gamble v. U.S. is the interplay between the briefs of the parties and the oral argument, This assignment asks you to trace specific examples of arguments in Petitioner’s (Gamble’s) Brief to specific sections of the oral argument.

Below are 5 arguments from the Gamble Brief. For each one
a) give a short statement of the point that Gamble is making;
b) give a short statement of the reply to that point that the Respondent (U.S.) makes;
c) find two Justices in the oral argument that ask a question or express a concern that is related to the argument from the Gamble brief, and briefly explain the point that each Justice is making. Cite to the page and line of the beginning of the Justice’s question as [page]:[line], e.g.: “21:13” for page 21 beginning at line 13.

1. I(C)(2) (“In the same vein...”)
2. II (This one is a general argument: stare decisis generally should not be an obstacle to getting rid of the dual sovereign exception)
3. II(B) (“Stare decisis loses its force...”)
4. II(D) (“The separate-sovereigns exception...”)
5. II(E) (“Finally, no reliance interests...”)

Here is an example of the format that I’m looking for, with I(C)(1) (“Fear and abhorrence...) as the argument prompt. (I’m making up some of the oral argument):

a) Gamble is saying that prohibiting successive prosecutions is exactly the point of the Double Jeopardy Clause. The purpose of the bar is to prevent the unfairness of prosecutors getting two bites at the apple, and that letting two prosecutors each get one bite is just as unfair as one prosecutor getting two bites.
b) The U.S. replies that it is not inherently “unfair” to have separate sovereigns protecting their own separate interests. Any particular cases of unfairness can be dealt with by policymakers, not as a flat, all-encompassing, invariable constitutional decree.
c) At 21:13, Sotomayor asks Chaiten why the dual-sovereign exception is unfair, since the prosecutors represent two separate governments. What’s unfair about that, she asks. The point of this question is to undermine Chaiten’s basic argument about the inherent unfairness of a second prosecution. While allowing the same prosecutor to take a second bite is unfair, she suggests that there's n othing wrong as long as the government is a different one.
At 50:3 Ginsburg asks Feigin why this very prosecution of Gamble is not unfair. In this routine case, why should a federal prosecutor get another shot at Gamble, and an additional punishment after Gamble’s already been convicted by the state. The point of this question is to attack Feigin’s position that there’s no unfairness here. Ginsburg says that it looks like being put twice in jeopardy for the same crime from the perspective of the defendant Gamble.


The paper should have five sections tracking the five arguments, labeled as in the example. I expect the sections to be about a third to a half page long or so, so a total of around 2 or 3 pages for the assignment.

Do no outside research. This assignment is totally based on what’s in the handouts of the briefs, and the oral argument itself.

Don’t give any introduction to the paper, or history of the case, etc. Just get right to the analysis. No fluff.

Be as specific as possible. Make your language as clear and simple as possible. Use your own words.

The assignment will be graded on both the structure and the content of your analysis. The paper will also be graded on how well you write English, and how clearly you organize your thoughts. I like short clear sentences better than long complicated ones. I like correct grammar.

Please make two copies of your paper, one to hand in at the beginning of class, and the other for you to have during class for our discussion

You may e-mail me if you have specific questions about the assignment. The more time that I have to answer your questions, the more likely it is that I can be helpful.

I am the only person with whom you can discuss, question, clarify, etc. any aspect of this assignment.

The work should be entirely your own, with no collaboration or plagiarism. Do not show your paper to anyone. Do not look at anyone else’s paper. Do not troll the internet for other people’s analysis. The idea is to think it out for yourself. See the syllabus regarding plagiarism and collaboration.

The assignment is due at the beginning of class on Thursday 2/14. If you cannot be in class on that day, you should still e-mail me your assignment by the beginning of the class. If you do that, you will not have any grade deducted from your grade for the paper. If you do not, you should still contact me as soon as possible to see what options are available to you. See the Syllabus for the class rules regarding late papers.



IMPORTANT: If you e-mail your assignment to me, I will reply to confirm that I have received your assignment. If you do not get a reply, then I have not received the assignment.


The assignment for Thursday 2/7 is to begin work on Assignment #1, and to read the Timbs briefs distributed today. Also listen to the Institute for JUstice podcast found at
https://ij.org/sc_long_podcast/all-but-redacted-the-privileges-or-immunities-clause/

Thursday, January 31, 2019

January 31, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Thursday 1/31, I distributed one handout, my version of the Doe case brief. We went over all of the case brief segments, including the inclusion of the loser's facts in an "even though" parenthetical. Along the way, we also went over the organization of the federal court system, and the 2 bases of federal trial court jurisdiction.
The assignment for Tuesday 2/5 is to review today's handout, review pp. 1-15 of the text (previously assigned) and then to read through p. 21 of the text (Miller v. Alabama). Using today's handout and the case brief template, write out a case brief of the Miller opinion (not handed in or graded).


POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Thursday 1/31, I first let the class know of upcoming assignment plans. I plan to distribute Assignment #1 on Tuesday 2/5, to be due Thursday 2/14. That's the plan, at least.
We then went back into the Gamble oral argument. We started with Alito's challenge on p. 10--"are you really ready to let the terrorist off the hook"? We looked at the response given, and then went to Black's dissent in Abbate, in which he had said, "well, that's what the double jeopardy clause is all about". I showed a clip from the PBS series on the Supreme Court in which Black said that the Bill of Rights does indeed make it harder to convict defendants (and that's the price we pay for protecting individual rights and dignity). I went over the history of incorporation of the Bill of Rights as protections as well as against the states, and discussed Benton v. Maryland.
The assignment for Tuesday 2/5 is to continue reviewing the Gamble oral argument.

Tuesday, January 29, 2019

January 29, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Tuesday 1/29, we finished putting the Doe case into English. We looked at the various issues decided by the Court, and we looked as well at how the Court suggested to DHHS (in footnote #9) how they should fix their problem. Along the way, we also discussed the concept of dictum. We began the process of putting the case into the format of the case brief template that I had distributed last Thursday, and got as far as the Plaintiff's Cause of Action. We will pick up with the Trial Court Defense on Thursday.
The assignment for Thursday 1/31 is to continue the process of putting Doe into the case brief format. Also, read in the text through p. 15.


POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Tuesday 1/29, I distributed one handout, the Ginsburg/Thomas concurrence in Puerto Rico v. Sanchez Valle in which they invited the issue was raised by Gamble. We started our journey through the Gamble oral argument. We talked about the original meaning "chain" tied to Chaiten in terms of the temptation to limit his argument to state/federal governments and thus avoiding foreign country complications. We looked at three types of questions asked during oral argument: hostile, lifeline, and actual questions. We got to Alito's question on p. 10, and I asked the class to think about the best answer to give to that question.
The assignment for Thursday 1/31 is to review the Gamble oral argument. Read it, and read it again. Look for how and where each piece of Chaiten's argument from his brief is attacked during the oral argument.

Thursday, January 24, 2019

January 24, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Thursday 1/24, I distributed 2 handouts: the Maine Constitution's Declaration of Rights, and the case brief template. We went through the Doe timeline, and went through the beginning of the Doe opinion with a fine-tooth comb. Along the way we went over Maine Supreme Court case citation form, and Maine statutory citation form. We went over de novo review for questions of law versus substantial evidence review for questions of fact. We started into the issues dealt with by the Court. We got through the first of the issues discussed in ¶13 of the opinion, which is where we'll pick up next Tuesday.
The assignment for Tuesday 1/29 is to re-read Doe with as much detail we we went over the case today. Also, using the case brief template try to put the Doe opinion into the format of the template (not handed in or graded, but do try your hand at it).



POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Thursday 1/24, we began going over the Gamble briefs. We looked at the structure and outline of the briefs, and how the federal government met each of Gamble's contentions. We got as far as ¶I(C)(1) of Gamble's argument, which is where we'll pick up on Tuesday.
The assignment for Tuesday 1/29 is to read and listen to the oral argument in Gamble. The preferred site to listen to the argument is
https://www.oyez.org/cases/2018/17-646
You will also need to have the transcript of the argument with you in class. You can get it from
https://www.supremecourt.gov
select oral_arguments
select argument transcripts
select argument session November 26-December 6
select Gamble, docket #17-646, 12/06/2018

Tuesday, January 22, 2019

January 22, 2019

POS 282 INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Tuesday 1/22, I distributed 3 handouts: the syllabus; the Maine Supreme Court opinion in Doe v. DHHS; and some questions to guide your reading of the Doe case. We went through the syllabus and the requirements for the class. I went over the organization of the Maine court system, with its 2 trial courts and one supreme court. We talked about how one gets to be Maine judge or justice, and the term for which one serves. We contrasted the Maine system with the lifetime tenure of the federal judges and justices. We began our discussion of the Doe case by going over the citation for the case, including the order of the parties in the caption. We went over the panel of justices of the court, and the first sentence of the opinion. We will pick up from that point on Thursday.
The assignment for Thursday 1/24 is to read the Doe opinion, and the questions about Doe that I had distributed. Also, be prepared with any questions stemming from your reading of Doe that the case raises for you, in terms of what was going on.


POS 359 THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Tuesday 1/22, I distributed 4 handouts: the syllabus; a list of the Supreme Court Justices and selected websites about the Court; and excerpts from both the Petitioner's and Respondent's briefs in Gamble v. U.S. We went through the syllabus and the requirements for the class. I discussed the path to the Supreme Court, through both the federal and the state courts systems, and the two major types of cases taken by the Court (interpretations of the federal constitution, and of the federal statutes). We looked over the biographies of the Justices. We began our discussion of the Gamble case by looking at the language of the 5th Amendment, and wondering what the words of the Double Jeopardy Clause mean in the context of the facts of the Gamble case
The assignment for Thursday 1/24 is to review the List of Justices handout, and then read in detail both the Petitioner's and the Respondent's briefs.