Tuesday, January 10, 2012

January 10, 2012

POS 282-- Introduction to American Law
In class today, Tuesday 1/10, I distributed one handout, the Syllabus. We went over the Syllabus, and the use of this Blog. I then discussed a case that was argued before the U.S. Supreme Court yesterday, Sackett v. EPA, regarding the rights of alleged polluters to go to court to stop the enforcement of environmental laws. The assignment for Thursday 1/12 is to read pp. 1-21 of the textbook.

POS 359--The Current Supreme Court Term
In class today, Tuesday 1/10, I distributed six handouts: the syllabus; a list of Justices and of useful websites; the January calendar for the Supreme Court oral arguments this month; and three columns about the Court and current politics:
•an article by George Will about Newt Gingrich--
http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/gingrich-the-anti-conservative/2011/12/20/gIQALq8CAP_story.html
•an article by Erwin Chemerinsky, also about Newt Gingrich--
http://articles.latimes.com/2011/dec/20/opinion/la-oe-chemerinsky-fedjudges-20111220
and an article by Linda Greenhouse about decision-making by the Justices--
http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/12/28/what-we-think-about-when-we-think-about-the-court/

I went over the syllabus, the Justices of the Court, and began a discussion of the Sackett case that was argued on Monday. The assignment for Thursday 1/12 is to read the three articles that I distributed today.

Thursday, December 8, 2011

December 8, 2011

POS 282--INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Thursday 12/8, we finished our discussion of the McIntyre v. Nicastro Supreme Court decision. I then went over two cases regarding the ownership of land in Maine as a basis for personal jurisdiction, Commerce Bank v. Dworman and Tidwell v. Zawacki. We switched to subject-matter jurisdiction, and went over the Edwards v. Direct Access case from the textbook. Finally, I went over a case recently argued before, but not yet decided by, the U.S. Supreme Court, Mims v. Arrow Financial. We will have exam #2, open-book and open-note, at 9:30 - 10:45 on Thursday 12/15. If there is an emergency that prevents your attendance at the exam, you must e-mail me as soon as possible.

POS 359--THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
In class today, Thursday 12/8, I distributed one handout, the oral argument schedule that the Court has followed for the past two weeks. We spent a little time going over the Zivotofsky paper, which is due by e-mail at noon on Thursday 12/15. I clarified that you must reach and discuss the Congressional power issue, even if your view is that the case is not justiciable. If you would like to get your paper back at the beginning of next semester, let me know. I then went over the highlight reel of the last two weeks' worth of Supreme Court oral arguments. I wish you all a good holiday break.

Tuesday, December 6, 2011

December 6, 2011

POS 282--INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW
In class today, Tuesday 12/6, I handed back the Schroeder case briefs. I also distributed two handouts; the comment key to the briefs, and my own version of the Schroeder brief. The class did class evaluations. We went over the Bohlander personal jurisdiction case. I went over the three methods of obtaining general personal jurisdiction over a defendant, and contrasted general jurisdiction with specific jurisdiction. We then started going over the recent U.S. Supreme Court case of McIntyre v. Nicastro. I discussed the plurality opinion that said it was not enough to foresee that a product would enter the stream of commerce; instead, there must be specific targeting into a particular state. I will contrast this with the concurring and dissenting opinions on Thursday. On Thursday as well I will discuss some Maine personal jurisdiction cases. We will also go over the previously assigned subject-matter jurisdiction case of Edwards. There is no additional reading for Thursday; just review Edwards.

POS 359--THE CURRENT SUPREME COURT TERM
UPDATE: The final vote was 6-5 saying that the case was justiciable, and also 6-5 saying that Congress does have the power to direct the State Department in this way. Zivotofsky wins!


In class today, Tuesday 12/6, I distributed one handout, Assignment #3 which is reproduced below. The class filled out class evaluations. We then did our Case Conference. The votes were as follows: 5-3 to find that the case is justiciable; and 4-4 on whether Congress has the power to direct the State Department in this matter. After polling the absent class members, I will update this blog regarding the final vote. That vote will tell you whether you are writing a majority or dissenting opinion for Assignment #3.

Assignment #3
You are the 10th Supreme Court Justice. Your job as a Justice is to write an opinion in the Zivotofsky v. Clinton case.

What you write for an opinion will be based on your view of how the case should be decided. What type of opinion you will be writing (majority; concurring; dissenting; combination) will depend on how the class votes at our case conference on Tuesday 12/6.

Here are some guidelines for writing that I want you to observe:

• You should deal specifically with the issues raised by the side that is opposed to your view of the case. What’s wrong with the positions taken by the other Justices?

• You should have at least three specific references to the oral argument. Your citations to the oral argument transcript should give page and line numbers.

• If it fits into you Opinion, you should include a reference to the class oral argument (posted on the blog) and to the class Case Conference.

• You should deal specifically with both issues that were the issues presented in the case; justiciability (should the Court be hearing this case in the first place?) and distribution of powers (was Congress acting within its powers when it passed the law?)

• You should deal with other sub-issues as you locate them in the briefing and the oral argument.


You should use primarily your own words, quoting only in snippets when the particular words of an exchange or a brief are crucial.


Here’s a fictitious example to demonstrate the format that I’m looking for:

This Court rejects Clinton’s position that the Executive branch has exclusive power to decide what the contents of a passport are. While her brief argues that Congress has no constitutional right to conduct foreign policy, at oral argument Verilli conceded that the Government’s only textual claim was based on the authority of the Executive to receive foreign ambassadors (17:6). This is too thin a reed to bear the weight of exclusive executive passport authority.

The paper should be a minimum of 3 pages long, and no more than 5 pages. Brevity should be seen as an asset, not a liability. It will be due at noon on Thursday December 15. You should e-mail the paper to me by that time. I will acknowledge receipt of papers--if you don’t get an acknowledgment, that means that I didn’t get the paper. See the syllabus for more information, or if you do not have the paper done on time.

The paper will not be graded on whether I agree with your analysis of how the case should be decided, but rather by how well you identify specific sub-issues, evaluate them, and support your position. The paper will also be graded on how well you write English, and how clearly you organize your thoughts. Try using an outline. I encourage you to use the UM writing center to help with your English.

The work should be entirely your own, with no collaboration, and no plagiarism.

Thursday, December 1, 2011

December 1, 2011

POS 282--Introduction to American Law
In class today, Thursday 12/1, the class handed in the Schroeder case briefs, and we went over them. I distributed one handout, hypotheticals which can be used to test which facts were the key ones for the Court. I plan to hand back those Schroeder case briefs on Tuesday. We will also get over the previously assigned Bohlander case on Tuesday. The additional assignment for Tuesday 12/6 is to read the Edwards case on p. 157 of the text.

POS 359--The Current Supreme Court Term
In class today, Thursday 12/1, the class had our own oral argument in the Zivotofsky v. Clinton case. Following is a summary of that oral argument. The assignment for Tuesday 12/6 is to prepare for a judicial conference on the case. The class will share their opinions, try to persuade others, and then vote on how the case will be decided. This vote will form the basis of the final paper assignment, which will be to write an opinion, which will be some form of majority, concurrence, and dissent.

December 1, 2011
ORAL ARGUMENT OF 10-699, ZIVOTOFSKY V. CLINTON
Question 1 (to Clinton advocates): In Israel, there is only one international airport. It was said by government advocates that people would be offended by putting Jerusalem, Israel on passports. My question is whom would it offend in this case? Who would know?
Answer 1: It would offend Palestinians, because there is recognition that Jerusalem is Israel’s territory, and distinctly not Palestine’s. There may be Palestinians traveling through Israel, who are from Jerusalem, and it would identify them as being born in Israel. This land is at dispute between these two different countries. Recognizing the city as distinctly being on one side is playing favorites. This court’s decision will be made public immediately; this information is not private. Everyone could know.

Question 2 (to Clinton advocates): With the executive not wanting or not recognizing the capital of Israel being Jerusalem, isn’t it by default saying that it doesn’t belong to Israel and instead belongs to Palestine?
Answer 2: We believe that the United States should see Jerusalem as neutral, as controlled by neither Palestine nor Israel. Put neither Israel nor Palestine on the passport

Question 3 (To Clinton advocates): Question 4: Do you think the President is the one who should make the decision? It could change every four years. Even the neutrality you suggest is dependent upon future president’s reaffirming it.
Answer 3: We do support the idea that the President should decide. We are trying to maintain diplomatic ties with all countries. I think it is an executive decision. If we stay neutral, we can let them take care of it themselves. It is the position we are in now, and we feel that staying neutral is the best course of action. The executive branch is the best choice when dealing with volatile situations because he doesn’t have to deal with the bureaucracy of a congressional body.

Question 4 (to Clinton advocates): How do Palestinians have an argument when they aren’t recognized as a state? How are you giving a choice if Israel is recognized and Palestine is not? Isn’t cutting funding for a branch of the UN for their recognition of Palestine a bigger show of support than listing a city on a passport?
Answer 4: Just because we don’t recognize Palestine as a state, that doesn’t mean it isn’t an area with a civilization. It doesn’t mean they aren’t dangerous. We want to stay neutral, so we aren’t picking favorites or taking sides, especially in the Middle East. As far as the cutting of the UN branch’s funding, it’s debatable if that is a bigger show of choosing sides.

Question 5: (to Clinton advocates) Do you think Congress has the power of recognition?
Answer 5: No we do not.

Question 6: (to Zivotofsky advocates) What’s the role of Congress in the decision-making process? Congress has exercised power over passports before.
Answer 6: Congress intentionally gave some power to the president, under the assumption that the President has the power to recognize foreign nations.

Question 7: (to Zivotofsky advocates) What about the rest of the world? Is this a bigger reflection about our foreign policy? What happens when foreign airports see these passports?
Answer 7: We are trying to give people a choice. We aren’t trying to decide what Israel owns and what they don’t own. We are giving them the opportunity to say they are from Israel, which they could use in place of Jerusalem on their passports.

Question 8: (to Zivotofsky advocates) What is the line between Presidential and Legislative power? Where does it fall? Would Congress be able to recognize states?
Answer 8: We do believe that this falls within Congress’ power. We aren’t implying that Congress should have full power over foreign relations. The executive has power when it comes to foreign policy. We are looking to maintain recognition.

Question 9: (to Zivotofsky advocates) This isn’t just an Israel / Palestine issue, this passport can travel the world. This is a reflection on our foreign policy to the entire world.
Answer 9: It’s up to the individual American citizen. The passport wouldn’t be offensive; it would only read “Israel”.

Question 10 (to Zivotofsky advocates): In your ideal ruling what is the line between the President and Congress on the issue of passports?
Answer 10: Congress has all power over passports.

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

November 29, 2011

POS 282-Introduction to American Law
In class today, Tuesday 11/29, we began by going over several questions and concepts of the Schroeder case and case brief. We then went back into Choice of Law Rules with the Land case. We finished the personal jurisdiction case of Karstetter. The assignment for Thursday 12/1 is to finish the Schroeder case brief, which is due at the beginning of class on 12/1. Also review the Bohlander personal jurisdiction case which was previously assigned.

POS 359-The Current Supreme Court Term
In class today, Tuesday 11/29, we spent the class period going over the oral argument in MBZ v. Clinton. I also reviewed the Youngstown Sheet and Tube case, (the steel seizure case) regarding the relationship between Congressional and Executive authority. Thursday we will have our own oral argument, building on the Supreme Court's oral argument. Four people in class were designated as advocates, and five as Justices, with teams representing the Executive and Zivitofsky. Then next Tuesday we will convene as the Court Conference, each class member saying how they think the case should be decided, and then voting. The final paper will be based on the classroom oral argument and Conference, as well as the Supreme Court oral argument. That final paper will now be due December 15, one week after the last day of class.

Tuesday, November 22, 2011

November 22, 2011

POS 282--Introduction to American Law
In class today, Tuesday 11/22, I distributed one handout, assignment #2, which is reproduced below, and which is due Thursday 12/1. We began our discussion by going over the Hubbard case, and the concept of common law choice of law rules. I added two Maine Supreme Court cases to the mix, Collins v. Trius and Flaherty v. Allstate Insurance. The case brief assignment regards choice of law rules in the context of a contract dispute. We then started our discussion of personal jurisdiction and full faith and credit by wading into the situation in the Karstetter case. We will continue with Karstetter when we reconvene after the Thanksgiving holiday. The assignment for Tuesday 11/29 is to read two additional cases in the text, Land, starting on p. 180, and Bohlander, starting on p. 162. In addition begin work on the case brief assignment.



Assignment due Thursday, December 1, 2011
The assignment (graded) is to do a Case Brief of the case of Schroeder v. Rynel,
1998 ME 259, 720 A2d. 1164. The case can be found on the website of the Maine Supreme Court.

To access the case, go to
http://www.courts.state.me.us/opinions_orders/supreme/publishedopinions.shtml

--scroll down to “1998 Opinions”

--select 1998 ME 259, Schroeder v. Rynel (12/9/98)
or you can go directly to http://www.maine.gov/COURTS/opinions_orders/supreme/opinions_1998.html

Brief all of the issues that you determine that the Court ruled on.

Follow the format from the Sample Briefs that I’ve distributed. Note especially that the Facts, Issues, and Holding are copied and pasted. Everything that you put into the Fact section should appear exactly in your Issue and Holding sections as well. Your Issue and Holding sections should be identical to each other, except that the issue is a question, and the Holding is the answer to that question. Your briefs will be evaluated on the format, as well as the specific content.

Please make two copies of your brief, one to hand in at the beginning of class, and the other for you to have during class for our discussion.

You may e-mail me if you have questions about the brief. The more time that I have to answer your questions, the more likely it is that I can be helpful.

If you cannot be in class on Thursday 12/1, you should still e-mail me your brief by the beginning of class time. If you do that, you will not have any grade deducted from your grade for the brief. If you do not, you should still contact me as soon as possible to see what options are available to you. (Generally, I do not want to accept assignments after we have discussed them in class). See the Syllabus for the class rules regarding late papers. Remember to work by yourselves; do not collaborate.

IMPORTANT: If you e-mail your brief to me, I will reply to confirm that I have received your assignment. If I do not reply, then I have not received the assignment.


POS 359--The Current Supreme Court Term

In class today, Tuesday 11/22, I handed back the Jones papers, and we briefly went over them. We started our discussion of MBZ v. Clinton, going over the Court of Appeals decision, and the two different ways in which the government can, and did, win the case. We went over four of the leading Supreme Court justiciability cases that were part of the Court of Appeals decision. We also discussed how to structure the remaining classes and assignments. Here's the plan we came up with: the assignment for Tuesday 11/29 is to read the Supreme Court oral argument in the case, as well as the "Summary of Argument" in both the Petitioner's and Respondent's briefs. We will go over that oral argument during Tuesday's class. Then on Thursday, 12/1, we will have our own oral argument ("The Return of Zivotofsky")in which some class members will get to grill others to defend their positions regarding how the case should be decided. The final paper, due the last day of class, will then basically be a "how would you decide the case" type of question, but informed by not only the Supreme Court's oral argument, but also the oral argument that we hold in class. Hopefully it will all work out, but I hope that you first work out a way to have a good Thanksgiving.

Thursday, November 17, 2011

November 17, 2011

POS 282--Introduction to American Law
In class today, Thursday 11/17, we first went over the Apsey case, and then the Michigan Supreme Court reversal of that Court of Appeals decision. I then went over the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision of Davis v. U.S., in which the Court ruled that the retroactivity rules regarding 4th Amendment decisions do not automatically also apply to the remedy of exclusion of evidence of unconstitutional searches and seizures. We compared the retroactivity rules laid out by the U.S. Supreme Court in Griffith v. Kentucky with those of the Apsey court. We then discussed the Strunk case regarding the absence of precedent. The assignment for Tuesday 11/22 is to read and be prepared to discuss pp. 140-149 of the text. On Tuesday 11/22 I will also distribute the next briefing assignment for the class, which will be due on Thursday 12/1.

POS 259--The Current Supreme Court Term
In class today, Thursday 11/17, we went over the Jones predictions, and I collected the papers. I plan to grade them this weekend, and return them on Tuesday. The assignment for Tuesday 11/22 is to read the Court of Appeals decision in our next case, Zivotofsky v. Clinton, 571 F.3d 1227 (D.C. Cir., 2009). This is the case that came in second in our last balloting. I will also be soliciting your opinions about a preferred specific assignment for the Zivotofsky case.