Thursday, October 20, 2011

October 20, 2011

POS 282--Introduction to American Law
In class today, Thursday 10/20, I began by going over federal court jurisdiction, both diversity jurisdiction and federal question jurisdiction. I had a sample test for the class, going over the types of questions that you might expect on Tuesday's test. We then finished the Lawrence case, and also discussed Connecticut v. Doe. The assignment for Tuesday 10/25 is to prepare for the open-book, open-note test on Tuesday. It will cover all of the material covered in class thus far.

POS 359--The Current Supreme Court Term
In class today, Thursday 10/20, we went over the Essex County Brief, and the Carter Phillips oral argument in which Phillips occasionally defended that brief. The assignment for Tuesday October 25 is to read two Court of Appeals decisions in this line of cases. One is the Florence 3rd Circuit decision, Florence v. Board, 621 F.3d 296 (3rd Cir., 2010) and the other is an older First Circuit case, Roberts v. Rhode Island, 239 F.2d 107 (1st. Cir., 2001). These opinions can be accessed from the Fogler site by going to library.umaine.edu; select Indexes and databases; select Lexis Nexis Academic, and put in the citation. You should also be working on your Opinions, which are due on Thursday 10/27.

Tuesday, October 18, 2011

October 18, 2011

POS 282--Introduction to American Law
In class today, Tuesday 10/18, I began by letting the class know that we will have Test #1 on Tuesday 10/25. The test will be open-book and open-note. On Thursday 10/20 I will go over some sample questions. We then finished our discussion of the Glucksberg case, tracing the process by which the Court decided that the asserted right was not "fundamental". We then went to Lawrence v. Texas, and looked at the process there in terms of defining the right and deciding whether it was fundamental. We left off with the question of how Justice Kennedy analyzed the "legitimate" state interest involved. We will pick up with that question on Thursday, as well as going over the previously assigned case of Connecticut v. Doe (p.44) The assignment for Thursday 10/20 is to review Lawrence and Doe.

POS 359--The Current Supreme Court Term
In class today, Tuesday 10/18, I distributed Assignment #1, which is reproduced below, and which is due Thursday, October 27. After going over that assignment, we went into a discussion of the oral argument in Florence, comparing the position taken by Goldstein at oral argument with the positions taken in the Florence brief. I also went over an additional case, Atwater v. City of Lago Vista (2001) in which the Court upheld the constitutionality of an arrest of a woman for a seatbelt violation. The assignment for Thursday 10/20 is to read the brief of respondent Essex County, again comparing the positions taken in the brief with those taken at oral argument.

Assignment #1
Good news! In order to foster a more youthful outlook at the Supreme Court, Congress has increased the membership of the Court to ten, and you, because of your outstanding dedication to The Law, have been chosen to be that 10th Justice.
Your first job as a new Justice is to write the Court’s opinion in the Florence v. Board case.
Your opinion is not a prediction of the votes; don’t worry about the other Justices, just concentrate on reaching and justifying the decision that you think makes the most sense. Where you cite to the oral argument, you’re looking to the response of the lawyers rather than the viewpoint expressed by the other Justices.

Since this will be your first Supreme Court opinion, here are some guidelines for writing that I want you to observe:
• You should deal specifically with the issues raised by the party that is opposed to your view of the case. What’s wrong with the argument raised by the losers, both in their brief and in the oral argument?
• You should have at least two specific references to each party’s position in the briefs (two for Florence and two for Essex County) , with specific reference to the page number of the argument.
• You should have at least three specific references to the oral argument. Your citations to the oral argument transcript should give page and line numbers.
• You should deal specifically with how Bell is to be interpreted in light of the present case.
• You should deal with other sub-issues as you locate them in the briefing and the oral argument.

You should use primarily your own words, quoting only in snippets when the particular words of an exchange or a brief are crucial.

Because of the particular factual situations raised by this case, it would be helpful for us to use a common vocabulary. Please use these terms with these meanings:
Visual strip search: observing the naked body of the arrestee, with no particular cavity focus.
Visual cavity search: close observation of the body cavity, with the arrestee opening his mouth, etc.
Squat and cough: just like it sounds.
Cavity search: digital search by the jailers of body cavities.
Here’s a fictitious example to demonstrate the format that I’m looking for:

This Court rejects Florence’s position that the reasonableness of the visual cavity search depends on the proximity of the jailer to the arrestee. While his brief argues that the state has no constitutional right to conduct a visual cavity search absent probable cause (Florence Brief, p. 47), at oral argument he conceded that such routine practices do not require probable cause at all, and that the only constitutional question is the proximity of the jailer to the arrestee (17:6). We refuse to establish such a yard-stick test as a principle of our constitution.

The paper should be a minimum of 3 pages long, and no more than 5 pages. Brevity should be seen as an asset, not a liability. It will be due at the beginning of the class on Thursday October 27. If you are unable to attend class on that date, you should e-mail the paper to me by the beginning of class. I will acknowledge receipt of any e-mailed papers--if you don’t get an acknowledgment, that means that I didn’t get the paper. See the syllabus for more information, or if you do not have the paper done on time.

The paper will not be graded on whether I agree with your analysis of how the case should be decided, but rather by how well you identify specific sub-issues, evaluate them, and support your position. The paper will also be graded on how well you write English, and how clearly you organize your thoughts. Try using an outline. I encourage you to use the UM writing center to help with your English.

The work should be entirely your own, with no collaboration, and no plagiarism.

As I write this assignment, the Supreme Court has not yet decided this case; naturally, I hope they don’t decide it before October 27, because that would really complicate the process of evaluating your analysis. But, if they do decide the case before then, I will post a modification to the assignment on the blog, as well as e-mail you through the MaineStreet portal. Be sure to check the blog (even if you don’t miss any classes) to see if the other Justices on the Court have written their views before receiving the benefit of your view.

Thursday, October 13, 2011

October 13, 2011

POS 282--Introduction to American Law
In class today, Thursday 10/13, I handed back the Price-Rite case briefs, as well as distributing a key to the numbered comments that I made on the briefs. We then finally went over the Maine criminal statute regarding use of force in defense of premises, and how it might relate to the situation in Katko v. Briney. We started our discussion of the Glucksberg case, going over the consequences of whether a right is put into the box called "fundamental" or not. We will pick up next Tuesday with an examination of how the Court went about figuring out which box to put this right into. The additional assignment for Tuesday 10/18 is to read in the text the case of Texas v. Lawrence, starting on p.83 of the text, and briefing the case for yourselves.

POS 359--The Current Supreme Court Term
In class today, Thursday 10/13, I distributed one handout, a Bangor Daily News editorial regarding strip searches and the Florence case. We went over several aspects of the Florence case and the Petitioners Brief: the vocabulary of "reasonable suspicion"; the vocabulary of strip searches; the four categories of questions of concern to the Justices that we discussed last week; and the precedents of Bell v. Wolfish and Turner v. Safley, and the way that the Florence brief tries to distinguish those cases. The assignment for Tuesday 10/18 is to read the oral argument transcript in the case, paying particular attention to those questions by the Justices that highlight ambiguities in the Petitioners brief, (At the end of the week the Court should also post the audio of that oral argument, so that you can listen and read along at the same time.)

Thursday, October 6, 2011

October 6, 2011

POS 282--Introduction to American Law
In class today, Thursday 10/6, the class handed in the Price-Rite briefs, and we spent the class period going over them. I will hand them back when we next meet on Thursday 10/13. The assignment for Thursday 10/13 is to read in the text pp. 28-46. It would be helpful to you to prepare a brief (at least the issues) of the Glucksberg and Connecticut v. Doe cases (although nothing will be passed in or graded).

POS 359--The Current Supreme Court Term
In class today, Thursday 10/6, the class first voted on which case which we should study for our first writing assignment. The winner was Florence v. Board of Chosen Freeholders, which will be argued on Wednesday October 12. The assignment for our next class meeting on Thursday October 13 is to read the Petitioner's Brief in that case. The brief can be accessed by going to the Supreme Court website, selecting Merits Briefs, then on-line merits briefs, and then (once you're at the ABA site) selecting Florence either through the alphabetical listing of cases or going through the October cases.
For the remainder of the class we discussed the Douglas oral argument again. I suggested four categories of questions that the Justices were asking: questions about the institutional implications of a decision (separation of powers, federalism); the practical implications of a ruling; the conformity with precedent; and the scope of the rule that should be established.

Tuesday, October 4, 2011

October 4, 2011

POS 282--Introduction to American Law
In class today, Tuesday 10/4, we went over various aspects of the State v. Price-Rite opinion. We went over the outline of the case, the idea of questions of law and questions of fact, subject-matter jurisdiction, and examples of bad lawyering committed by both sets of lawyers. The assignment for Thursday 10/6 is to complete the Price-Rite case brief, which is due at the beginning of class on Thursday. Please make two copies of your brief, one to hand in at the beginning of class, and one to use for our class discussion.

POS 359--The Current Supreme Court Term
In class today, Tuesday 10/4, I first gave a preview of an interesting case set for oral argument on Wednesday, Hosanna-Tabor Church V. EEOC. We spent the rest of the class doing a first pass over the Douglas oral argument. We looked at how the arguments made by Schwartz mirrored the structural power questions that we've previously discussed in class, and we also looked at the various types of issues that the Justices were concerned with. I also went over Gonzaga v. Doe, the 2002 Supreme Court decision that cut back the recognition of private causes of action in Spending Clause cases. The assignment for Thursday 10/6 is to read again the Davis oral argument, this time looking for the specific issues that the questions from the Justices centered around, and the viewpoints of the specific Justices as expressed in their questions.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

September 27, 2011

POS 282--Introduction to American Law
In class today, Tuesday 9/27, I distributed two handouts: my version of the Suggs v. Norris brief, and the graded briefing assignment for next Thursday 10/6. There will be no class meeting this Thursday 9/29. In class today, we discussed the issues of intent in both the majority and dissenting opinions in Katko, and the question of punitive damages in both of those opinions. We went over the Suggs v. Norris case and brief. I discussed the graded briefing assignment, (which is posted below). The assignment for our next class meeting on Tuesday 10/4 is to begin work on the case brief for State of Maine v. Price-Rite, 2011 ME 76. Also the website for the Attorney Generals Complaint in that case is http://www.maine.gov/ag/about/cases_of_interest.shtml

THERE WILL BE NO CLASS THURS. 9/29

Assignment due Thursday, October 6, 2011
The assignment (graded) is to do a Case Brief of the case of State of Maine v. Price-Rite Fuel, 2011 ME 76, ___ A3d. ____. The case can be found on the website of the Maine Supreme Court.

To access the case, go to
http://www.courts.state.me.us/opinions/supreme/index.html

--scroll down to “2011 Opinions”

--select 2011 ME 76, State of Maine v. Price-Rite Fuel (7/5/11)

Brief all of the issues that you determine that the Court ruled on.

Follow the format from the Sample Briefs that I’ve distributed. Note especially that the Facts, Issues, and Holding are copied and pasted. Everything that you put into the Fact section should appear exactly in your Issue and Holding sections as well. Your Issue and Holding sections should be identical to each other, except that the issue is a question, and the Holding is the answer to that question. Your briefs will be evaluated on the format, as well as the specific content.

Please make two copies of your brief, one to hand in at the beginning of class, and the other for you to have during class for our discussion.

You may e-mail me if you have questions about the brief. The more time that I have to answer your questions, the more likely it is that I can be helpful.

If you cannot be in class on Thursday 10/6, you should still e-mail me your brief by the beginning of class time. If you do that, you will not have any grade deducted from your grade for the brief. If you do not, you should still contact me as soon as possible to see what options are available to you. (Generally, I do not want to accept assignments after we have discussed them in class). See the Syllabus for the class rules regarding late papers. Remember to work by yourselves; do not collaborate.

IMPORTANT: If you e-mail your brief to me, I will reply to confirm that I have received your assignment. If I do not reply, then I have not received the assignment.



POS 359--The Current Supreme Court Term
In class today, Tuesday 9/27, we first decided that the class will watch the "John Marshall" episode of the PBS Supreme Court series on Thursday 9/29 (a day when I cannot be in class). So there will be an attendance sheet passed around on Thursday, and the class will watch that program. The assignment for Tuesday 10/4 is to read the transcript of the Douglas oral argument that will be held on Monday 10/3. The transcript should be posted on the Supreme Court website by around 2 or 3 o'clock on Monday. To get to the transcript, go to supremecourt.gov, select oral argument, and select oral argument transcript. The url is http://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/argument_transcripts.aspx
This is the case which we previously discussed that raises the question of whether the Supremacy Clause of the constitution itself supplies a cause of action for a challenge to California's Medicaid cutbacks. I'm not sure how technical the oral argument will be (how many unexplained precedents and doctrines will be brought up), but try to make sense of what the parties are arguing, and what the Justices are getting at in their questions to the advocates.

Thursday, September 22, 2011

September 22, 2011

POS 282--Introduction to American Law
In class today, Thursday 9/22 I distributed two handouts: my own version of the Katko brief, and the Maine criminal statute dealing with use of force in defense of property. We continued with our discussion of the Katko brief, getting as far as the first issue that the Court dealt with (can you set a spring gun under the circumstances?). We went through the authority that the Court relied upon in reaching its decision, secondary and primary authority, mandatory and persuasive authority. We will finish with Katko next Tuesday, first exploring the role of Briney's intent to injure, and the question of notice of the spring gun, and then finishing with the punitive damages issue and the disposition. The assignment for Tuesday 9/27 is to look over the two handouts. In addition, read in the text pp. 54 -57, and write out a brief (again, not handed in or graded) of the Suggs v. Norris decision.

POS 359--The Current Supreme Court Term
In class today, Thursday 9/22, we talked a little about the Davis execution in Georgia. Then I distributed a page of letters that were published this week about the Toobin New Yorker article , and we used the letters as a springboard to discuss such issues as the meaning of originalism, consistency v. flexibility and compromise in judging, and the rules for recusal. I also went over one more Supreme Court oral argument scheduled for the first week, Howes v. Fields, that raises the issue of when someone is in custody for Miranda purposes when the person is already imprisoned for another offense. The assignment for Tuesday 9/27 is to finish reading the Burns book.